Can a co-owner sell half of a house that someone else lives in?
It all depends. If they hold the property as tenants-in-common then it should be a bit more straightforward to sell their defined share, though the following issues may all still be relevant and arguably reduce the valuation. If joint owners own the property jointly and severally between them, with no separate right of ownership, each person's individual interest in the property should still have a value in principle. If another co-owner would be willing to buy them out, then the remaining question is just whether it's a realistic price. If the other co-owners are unable or unwilling to do that, then it becomes a relevant factor to know whether they would oppose a sale of the full property to anyone else.
The value of a joint owner's interest isn't necessarily calculated by simply dividing the full market value by the number owners, though that will generally be the starting point. In a case where another joint owner is still living in the property and is not interested in selling, then the market value of the co-owner's share should likely be reduced from an equal share of the full value.
How much should a joint owner's share be reduced for valuation purposes?
There have been many appeals on this point, but case law hasn't provided simple rule for saying how much discount should be applied. The Court of Appeal has established that the value of one owner's interest in a property owned by two people should be the market value of a half share, not one half of the value of the whole - but the appropriate discount to apply in order to take account of that could be:
- a discount of the entire value (as in CAO v Palfrey R(IS) 26/95), or
- a nominal or nil discount (as in Wilkinson v CAO R(IS) 1/01), or
- anything in between.
It all depends on the particular circumstances.
Who would buy, on the open market, a partial interest in a property that they can't take possession of?
In Northern Ireland case law (which may or may not be persuasive in Great Britain), Commissioner Stockman thought that the answer was 'nobody':
"I have no evidence that there is any real world market for a half-share in dwelling houses with the co-owner in occupation. It seems to me that, in a case such as the present one, if the Department cannot establish evidence of a real world market for such interests, then the value of such interests in the real world must be nil."
and
"...the “elephant in the room” is the lack of evidence of a real world market in half interests in property owned by tenants in common ... Where there is no market, it follows that the current market value of the respondent’s interest is likely to be, as the tribunal has found, nominal ... the LPS* valuation did not and could not point to evidence of sales of comparable interests."
* LPS is the Northern Ireland 'Land and Property Services', who will supply expert valuations to the DfC. In Great Britain, DWP have a similar agreement with the Valuation Office Agency, a copy of DWP's instructions for using that service is
here.
... but in the Upper Tribunal, Judge Jacobs has said:
"There is a market for investment in interests that do not allow immediate exclusive possession. That may not be widely known among claimants, but it has been referred to in a number of Upper Tribunal decisions. It may not be easy to produce evidence of that market, but its existence is not in doubt."
These cases could be cited in an appeal, but note that none of them are recent, and the property/investment market might have moved on since they were decided. In any event, the DWP are unlikely to accept without further evidence that a sale is impossible, just because there is a co-owner living in the property. The key point will be what the facts and evidence show about that in the claimant's own case.
What should claimants do?
Co-owners claiming benefit who can't qualify for a disregard, and so need to be assessed as owning a partial share of a property, should be prepared to provide as much information and evidence as they can of their particular situation. It should be in their interests to co-operate with DWP in obtaining an accurate value, and they should generally give consent to DWP carrying out a valuation if that is requested. They should also provide to DWP (whether they explicitly ask for it or not), any available evidence of:
- the other occupier's and/or other co-owner's attitude to moving out, or to selling?
- legal difficulties the claimant would have if they needed to get a court order for sale?
Relevant factors might include: if there is any charge on the property such as a mortgage, would the lender give any consent or refinancing that is required? does a joint tenancy need to be severed into tenants-in-common before a sale can be made? are there any ongoing disputes or legal proceedings - in particular, if a property is an asset currently in dispute by divorce proceedings, then case law has said that the right to receive future a payment or property transfer under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 has no current value.
- any practical difficulties they would face?
Examples could include: health or disability issues, or lack of access to support or advice and representation. Fear of violence from the resident ex-partner, for example, isn't necessarily a barrier to dealing with a sale but it could be relevant in some cases. If the property is overseas, does that present any special difficulties such as travel costs, or a language barrier? These are just examples, not a complete list.
- any valuation or professional opinion they have obtained?
An estate's agent valuation of the entire property likely won't give the full picture. Ideally a qualified valuer or solicitor would provide an opinion of the current market value - if any! - of the claimant's fractional beneficial interest. If steps have been taken to find a specialist property investor who would buy out the claimant's share, but no such purchaser can be found, then include the evidence of that search.
The DWP - or the appeals tribunal as the case may be - should take all this into account when valuing the claimant's share.