Housing Systems: Combating poverty and sustaining tenancies.
Search
Articles

UC Overpayments - always recoverable?

DWP's refusal to waive recovery can be unlawful

coinsPublished 21st October 2026

All overpayments of Universal Credit (UC) are recoverable debts under social security law. It does not matter who was at fault for any mistake which caused the overpayment. But the DWP should consider waiving a debt before seeking recovery.


Background

Claimants who are overpaid UC can't challenge the decision to recover through the social security appeals system. They can only challenge a decision regarding their actual entitlement, ie. if they can argue that DWP's decision on the amount of the overpayment was wrong because they should have been entitled to some or all of it. 

This is in contrast to other DWP benefits such as Pension Credit (or the old IR-ESA, IS and IB-JSA) for which overpayments are/were only recoverable if the claimant misrepresented or failed to disclose the material fact that caused the overpayment.^

^ Housing Benefit overpayments can also be not legally recoverable, in a slightly narrower set of circumstances: if they are due to an official error by the council, and the claimant couldn't reasonably have realised they were being overpaid.

Instead, social security legislation leaves the decision on whether to recover a UC overpayment entirely to DWP's discretion - they can chose to waive recovery - meaning they can choose not to recover an overpayment. However, in practice, DWP policy is to pursue debt recovery in almost all but very exceptional cases.


Claimants can ask the DWP to waive recovery of the overpayment

So whilst UC overpayments are always recoverable, the DWP can use their discretion to decide not to recover the debt, and the claimant can make that request - more details and a Standard Template here.

If the claimant^^ asks for recovery to be waived, then DWP should apply their waiver policy in Chapter 8 of the Benefit Overpayment Recovery Guide.  This waiver policy is now an important part of protecting vulnerable claimants, and ensuring that fairness is done.

Despite claimants being able to request a waiver, the number recorded in official statistics is low, and the number of requests that have been granted is even lower. 

UC is overpaid on a large scale. DWP statistics show that in 2023, 24% of all UC awards included some sort of overpayment - a total of £5.5 billion,, of which £250 million was recorded as due to official error. But when it comes to discretionary waivers only a tiny number were granted. In answer to a Freedom of Information Request, the DWP confirmed that in 2024/25 they received just 234 waiver requests, of which 100 were granted, waiving just £826,758.

^^ or the person from whom recovery is being sought.


What should a claimant do if they are unhappy with the DWP's decision to recovey a UC overpayment?

They should write to the Debt Recovery Team asking for them to waive the debt.

So, where a claimant^^ believes it would be particularly unfair and/or would cause them financial hardship and/or impact on their health or the health of their family, if a UC overpayment was recovered from them, then they can request the DWP waive the debt.

We have more information on what factors the DWP should consider and a Template Standard Letter here.

^^ or the person from whom recovery is being sought.


If DWP refuse to use their discretion to waive recovery of a UC overpayment, what can a claimant do?

1. A claimant can complain to DWP, about an unreasonable refusal to waive recovery

A complaint can be made to DWP about not waiving a debt. This could be done for example:

  • as soon as DWP have decided there is a recoverable overpayment, but it’s become clear they have not decided to consider a waiver. This will often be evident from the initial overpayment decision notice
  • if a debt waiver has been explicitly asked for, and DWP either refuse the request or else ignore it.

If not happy with the outcome of DWP's internal complaints process, they can ask for a review by the Independent Case Examiner (ICE). Complaints can also be escalated to the Public Service Ombudsman via the claimant's MP. See here on our site for more on the complaints procedure. 

However, it may be rare for a debt to be waived by escalating a complaint. Examples of ‘successful outcomes’ given by ICE in their annual reports include cases where complaints are made about how large UC overpayments have been administered by DWP. When ICE find that DWP was at fault they might recommend compensatory payments for distress caused or financial loss, but they don’t give any examples where ICE would consider recommending that a debt not be recovered.

 

2. A claimants could apply for a Judicial Review in the High Court of DWP’s decision to recover

The High Court (or Court of Session in Scotland) can review many types of decision made by public officials. A government decision such as a DWP decision not to waive recovery of a UC overpayment, can be changed or set aside, if it's found to be irrational or unlawful.


Relevant Case Law

There have been two notable High Court cases involving a refusal to waive a UC overpayment:

Case 1 R(K) v SSWP, [2023] EWHC 233 (Admin) 

The High Court decided that the DWP's refusal to waive recovery of a UC overpayment caused by official error in this case was unlawful. The claimant had repeatedly queried her entitlement with the DWP, who failed to spot their error. The court found that DWP:

  • should have considered if waiving the debt would be in the public interest,
  • did not adequately apply their own policy of taking account of how the overpayment arose and the debtor’s conduct,
  • had acted unlawfully by not publicly publishing its 'Decision Makers Guide to Waiver' (subsequently incorporated into the Benefit Overpayments Recovery Guide, in response to this case), and
  • was in breach of its Public Sector Equality Duty, by not assessing the risk and extent of any adverse impacts arising from its debt collection policy on those with disabilities.

Case 2 R(O) vs SSWP, [2025] EWHC 3683 (Admin) 

The High Court declared that the decision to not waive recovery of the UC overpayment in this case was unlawful, on five different grounds:

  • no adequate reasons were given for how the overpayment was caused, or whose fault it was, or why it was 'reasonable' under the DWP's overpayment recovery policy to claw it back. The court said: "A totally unreasoned benefits claw-back decision like that is unlawful on that basis alone."
  • there was no evidence that the DWP considered its power to waive the overpayment, ie. DWP had "fettered its discretion"
  • it was irrational to not take into account: "the overpayment being entirely the DWP's own fault, plus significant hardship to the family, three of whom were significantly disabled. Whilst the DWP has an obligation to protect public funds, its decision to claw back has ended up costing far more public funds in legal costs than £2,100."
  • "clawing-back the overpayment was disproportionate under [the European Convention on Human Rights] as it was not the family's fault and had a serious effect on them"
  • no regard was given to the impact on the family in light of their disabilities under section 149 of the Equality Act 2010.

The above two cases are the only ones so far where the courts have taken the decision on whether or not to waive a UC debt out of DWP's hands.

Other cases are likely to have been settled by DWP and so never reached the High Court ie after receiving a Pre-action Protocol Letter. This pre-action letter is a required preliminary step before commencing action in the court. It tells the other party what the dispute is about, why the claimant believe they have acted wrongly, and what the claimant want them to do to resolve it without going to court. There is generally no cost involved in sending in a pre-action letter.

This means it provides the claimant with an opportunity to have the case considered by DWP's legal team, and perhaps have some or all of the issues settled in the claimant's favour, without needing to run up any legal/court costs.


How do these High Court decisions help other claimants who are overpaid? 

The above two cases show that there can definitely be cases where it’s worth considering a Judicial Review, or at least the threat of one by sending a Pre-Action Protocol Letter. 

What these High Court decision don't do:

  • These decisions don't create case law which is binding on a DWP decision-maker, or which a social security appeals tribunal can apply
  • They don't mean DWP's general approach to waivers will necessarily change (though it might!).
  • They don't even mean that the overpayment in those particular cases can never be recovered by DWP. The decision to recover may have been unlawful in some way, but that doesn't necessarily mean the debt doesn’t now exist, or that it's impossible for DWP to go back and make a different decision to recover some or all of the same debt correctly, using a more lawful procedure.

But they do show that the courts can be willing and able to step in and decide that DWP's recovery decisions are unreasonable and need to be changed, potentially applying a wider set of criteria than that normally used by DWP Debt Management. 


Next steps

If DWP agree to waive a debt, the claimant should be advised to keep safe the written evidence of this, just in case it’s ever needed in future.

If DWP won’t agree to entirely waive a debt, there could be cases where they instead:

  • waive it in part
  • agree to suspend recovery for a period of time, pending some change of circumstances
  • agree to recover at a reduced rate.

If any of those would be an acceptable outcome for the debtor, they could also (or instead) be requested.

If a waiver request is refused, and the claimant wants to try applying for a Judicial Review of this decision, then they should be encouraged to get legal advice/representation. A Pre-Action Protocol Letter should not only include the above sorts of reasons for why the request should have been granted, but also reasons why the procedure DWP followed in arriving at the decision to not waive a debt was unlawful. Such potential reasons are bulled-pointed in the two case law summaries above, but they will depend on the exact situation. CPAG have a template JR letter - click here. More on Judicial Review here.

IMPORTANT: The usual maximum time limit to apply to court for Judicial Review in England and Wales is 3 months from the event being complained of, but action should always be started promptly. Sending the pre-action letter would not normally grant any extension of the 3 months, so that first step should be done as soon as possible.


NOTE: Correct at time of publication, subject to change

 

More Articles: