
Published 22nd January 2025
Many Universal Credit claimants have a Transitional Element included in their UC award.
The Transitional Element is at a fixed rate for the first UC Assessment Period. After that, it can be eroded or lost. The Transitional Element is eroded when a new Element is included or an existing Element is increased (except the Childcare Costs Element).
There has been a problem; some claimants have been made worse off overall due to the way the erosion rules have been applied. The group affected are those whose UC award included a Carer Element for them and then they became entitled to the LCWRA Element instead. Many of these claimants saw an overall drop in their UC award when they swapped from having the Carer Element to having the LCWRA Element, even though their needs had increased.
Example of what was happening: Paul is a single UC claimant. His UC included a Carer Element and a Transitional Element of £256. He had a Work Capability Assessment and was found to have an LCWRA in July 2024. So, his Carer Element was replaced by the LCWRA Element (he cannot get both). It was the full amount of the new Element i.e. the LCWRA Element that eroded his Transitional Element. As this was worth more than his Transitional Element, his Transitional Element was completely eroded. Paul lost both his TE of £256 and also the Carer Element £198.31, so a total loss of £454.31 - which has been replaced by the LCWRA Element worth £416.19 – leaving him £38.12 worse off overall.
However, in a recent Upper Tribunal decision - SSWP v MJ [2025] UKUT 035 (AAC) made on 29th January 2025 - the Judge found that the erosion of the Transitional Element that takes place when someone moves from having a Carer Element to having a LCWRA Element is unlawful discrimination; and that Reg 55(2) of the UC(TP) Regs 2014 which had allowed for that erosion should therefore be re-worded so that the Transitional Element is eroded by the net increase i.e. the difference between the Carer Element and the LCWRA Element rather than the whole of the Carer Element.
How it should now work: Paula is a single UC claimant. Her UC includes a Carer Element and a Transitional Element of £256. She has just had a Work Capability Assessment and has been found to have an LCWRA. So, her Carer Element is replaced by the LCWRA Element (she cannot get both). It is the difference between the Carer Element and the LCWRA Element i.e. the net increase that will erode her Transitional Element. So her Transitional Element of £256 is eroded by £217.88 (£416.19 - £198.31) to £38.12. And whilst she sees no immediate increase in her UC award, she is no worse off.
The Case
The claimant, MJ, was in receipt of Income-Related Employment and Support Allowance with a Severe Disability Premium when she made a claim for Universal Credit through natural migration in February 2018. Her UC included a Carer Element and a Transitional Element (or Transitional SDP Element). In October 2021 she became entitled to the LCWRA Element instead of the Carer Element. Her Transitional Element was eroded by the full amount of the LCWRA Element and at the same time she lost her Carer Element. This made her worse off overall.
MJ appealed to the First Tier Tribunal (FTT) and was successful. The FTT ruled that the drop in her income contravened her rights under the European Convention on Human Rights and was therefore discriminatory. The Secretary of State for Work and Pensions (SSWP) appealed to the Upper Tribunal.
The Upper Tribunal also decided that MJ had been unlawfully discriminated against. The drop in income contravened her rights under the European Convention on Human Rights, i.e. the combined effect of Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination) and the First Protocol of Article 1 ("A1P1" - the right to peaceful enjoyment of possessions). The UT decided that there could be one of two remedies that would change the way the wording of Reg 55 of the UC(TP) Regs 2014 was read / applied so as to only erode a Transitional Element by the difference between the Carer Element and LCWRA Element - in other words the net increase.
What should happen now, if a claimant with a Transitional Element swaps from having a Carer Element to a LCWRA Element?
The erosion of the Transitional Element should only be by the difference between the Carer and LCWRA Elements. Anyone whose Transitional Element is eroded by the full amount of the LCWRA Element should request a Mandatory Reconsideration of the DWP's decision to erode their Transitional Element - see our Standard Letter UC TP3.
Will this apply to claimants who move onto UC through the managed migration process?
Yes. Although MJ's Transitional Element was because they had moved onto UC through natural migration and were entitled to a Transitional SDP Element, the UC (TP) Regulations state that a Transitional SDP Element becomes a Transitional Element from the claimant’s second Assessment Period, and so Regulation 55 of the Universal Credit (Transitional Provision) Regulations - the one that erodes the Transitional Element - applies to both 'types' of Transitional Element.
I have a client whose Carer Element was replaced by the LCWRA Element last year and was worse off as a result. Does this UT decision help him?
Yes - although unless he had requested a MR of the decision AND received a MR Notice before 29th January 2025, the anti-test case rule^ will apply - it operates to prevent arrears of benefit being paid for a period prior to the date of the decision of an Upper Tribunal or court in similar cases.
^ Section 27(3) of the Social Security Act 1998.
The way we see it is - anyone who had a Carer Element and then this was replaced by the LCWRA Element and ended up worse off as a result will fall into three groups:
- Those who already had already challenged the erosion and had a Mandatory Reconsideration (MR) decision made before 29th January 2025 (refusing to revise the decision on erosion) can now lodge an appeal (if in time). The First Tier Tribunal (FTT) are not bound by the anti-test case rule. The claimant should refer to the MJ case in their appeal submission. The FTT should follow the MJ case and allow the appeal (and then the DWP should pay back pay all the way back to the Monthly Assessment Period in which they were awarded the LCWRA Element). See our Standard Text UC TP5.
- Those who already had requested an MR before 29th January 2025 but the MR decision was not made before that date – the DWP might, when considering the MR request, revise the original decision (and award back pay all the way back to when the LCWRA Element was included in their award) OR they might apply the anti-test case rule and agree to supersede the decision - we are assuming from the Assessment Period that starts on or after 29th January 2025. If they decide the latter, there would be no point in appealing to the FTT.
- Those who have not requested an MR can now request a supersession^ of the amount of their UC award, from 29th January 2025 onwards, on the grounds that it should be superseded in line with the MJ decision. It was an error of law to erode their TE by the full value of the LCWRA Element when it was awarded, and they are entitled to have that corrected. See our Standard Letter UC TP4.
^ Reg 35(5) of the UC etc Decision and Appeal Regs.
NOTE: When calculating entitlement to a Transitional Element as of 29th January 2025, we would expect that the DWP will take into account any changes that would have naturally eroded the Transitional Element - such as rent increase, the addition of a Child Element etc. Also the claimant may have had a change that meant they lost it altogether (such as becoming a couple).
NOTE: The anti-test case rule falls under the Social Security Act 1998. Some commentators are interested in how this interacts with the Human Rights Act 1998. If you are advising someone who is caught by the anti-test case rule, so cannot get back the full amount they lost, you could contact Child Poverty Action Group for further advice https://cpag.org.uk/welfare-rights/support-advisers/advice-line-advisers
What if the DWP appeal the Upper Tribunal decision?
The SSWP has three months from 10th February 2025 to apply for permission to appeal to the Court of Appeal from the Upper Tribunal. We do not know yet if this is likely to happen.
In the meantime, anyone whose Transitional Element is eroded by the full amount of the LCWRA Element when their Carer Element is replaced by a LCWRA Element should request a Mandatory Reconsideration of the DWP's decision to erode their Transitional Element - see our Standard Letter UC TP3. .
If the DWP seek and are given permission to appeal the Upper Tribunal's decision, then whilst that outcome is pending, the DWP would need to try not to breach the UT case law. They would be able to stay any other appeals that are made on the same issue. If the facts of a case were different enough that DWP believe the case law shouldn't apply to it, then DWP would continue to apply the rules as they see them working i.e. by eroding a claimant's Transitional Element.
Does this case law also help those whose LCW Element is replaced by the Carer Element?
We believe there is a strong argument to say it does. In the decision the Judge focused more on the unfairness of someone's needs increasing but their UC decreasing.
NOTE: Correct at time of publication, subject to change.