
Published 24th July 2024
New DWP guidance may benefit certain EEA and non-EEA nationals who have Pre-Settled Status but no right to reside for means-tested benefit purposes (eg. they do not have worker status, or retained worker status). Normally this would mean no entitlement to a benefit like UC, but this guidance says they could still be entitled if leaving them without benefit income would leave them destitute.
The new guidance follows the Court of Appeal’s decision in SSWP v AT that sets out the requirements for decision makers to consider whether claimants with Pre-Settled Status who have no other right to reside for the purpose of the habitual residence test (HRT) would be destitute if means-tested benefits are refused.
The AT case involved a Romanian national (AT) who was granted Pre-Settled Status under the EU Settlement Scheme (EUSS) in December 2020. Due to domestic violence she and her daughter moved to a refuge with her only income being Child Benefit. At that point she claimed UC which was refused on the basis of her not having a right to reside (such as being a worker, or having retained that status).
AT appealed to the First-tier Tribunal which held in May 2022 that without UC, AT and her daughter would not be able to live in dignified conditions and a benefit authority was required to check that a refusal of benefit would not expose them and any children to ‘an actual and current risk of violation of their fundamental rights’.
The DWP went on to appeal this decision, but in 2023 the Court of Appeal upheld it and stated that an individual assessment is required in all cases where a person covered by the Withdrawal Agreement (ie. because they have Pre-Settled Status) would otherwise be refused benefits on grounds they do not have a right to reside, in particular considering:
- whether a refusal of benefit would mean the claimant or their children was exposed to an actual and current risk that they could not live in the UK in dignified conditions
- an actual risk of not being able to live in the UK in dignified conditions was held to mean a risk of being without, even for a temporary period, sufficient resources to have adequate food, clothing and accommodation (including heating for that accommodation)
- the mere theoretical availability of section 17 Children Act support did not mean such applications could always be refused – what mattered was whether any Children Act support would actually and currently be provided at such a level so as to mitigate the risk
- whether the claimant is able to work – if so it is likely there is no actual risk of not being able to live in the UK in dignified conditions.
The DWP were refused permission to appeal to the Supreme Court in early 2024 and have since issued guidance in line with the judgment of the Court of Appeal - it states where a claimant with Pre-Settled Status has no other right to reside for the purpose of the HRT the decision maker must consider whether they meet the AT threshold before refusing benefit. Paragraph 14 states:
'The AT threshold for this guidance means the inability to ‘meet their most basic needs’ at present or in the near future and should be considered in all cases. The threshold is high and the claimant’s position must amount to extreme material poverty incompatible with human dignity. Areas to be considered for basic needs are:
- food;
- personal hygiene;
- clothing;
- housing; and
- adequate heating.'
There is also separate guidance specifically relating to UC – as this is a working age benefit, being unable to work is a key factor in meeting the AT threshold.
Where the AT threshold is met therefore, the benefit claim should be allowed. Other factors raised in the AT decision should still be detailed if applicable to evidence the reasons why the claimant is unable to meet their most basic needs – such as being unable to work or receiving insufficient support.
NOTE the guidance states that the AT case does not apply to:
- claims from non-EU national claimants, including those from Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein and Switzerland;
- claimants who were not in scope of the Withdrawal Agreement at the end of the transition period (31/12/20) as ‘they did not exercise a Treaty right such as being a worker, self-employed person, jobseeker, self-sufficient person, student, having a permanent right to reside, being a family member of all of the above, being within the initial 3 months of arrival in the UK, or having a retained or derived right of residence’;
- claims from those with Settled Status, a Certificate of Application (for the EU Settlement Scheme), or any other form of leave; or
- decisions considering entitlement before 12 December 2022.
However, it is arguable that the AT case does apply to non-EU national claimants, and those who were not residing in the UK by 31/12/20 – as long as they are covered by the Withdrawal Agreement. This would also include those with a pending application to the EU Settlement Scheme.
Anyone who is eligible for the EU Settlement Scheme (including non-EU nationals, those with a pending application to the Scheme and joining EEA/non-EEA family members) can argue that they are covered by the Withdrawal Agreement and recent cases at the First-tier Tribunal have also supported this.
NOTE: Correct at time of publication, subject to change.