Housing Systems: Combating poverty and sustaining tenancies.
Search
Articles

The Successful Legacy Appeals Compensation Scheme

Published 26th May 2026

On 14th May the Minister of State announced a new compensation scheme – The Successful Legacy Appeals Compensation Scheme.

It aims to compensate those UC claimants, who:

  • made a claim for UC because a legacy benefit they were receiving was terminated, and
  • challenged the termination decision and won, and
  • were worse off on UC.

The UC rules did not allow these claimants to return to their previous legacy benefits (sometimes called the ‘lobster pot’ effect). So, they were stuck on UC receiving less income even though it had been accepted that their legacy benefit was ended incorrectly. 

This compensation scheme follows the Court of Appeal decision TD, AD and R v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions [2020] EWCA Civ 618, and means that those affected by similar circumstances will not need to seek redress through the courts or a tribunal.

NOTE: This Scheme does not cover those who were misadvised to claim UC (i.e. it does not cover claimants who could have stayed on legacy benefits but were wrongly told to claim UC). 
 

IMPORTANT:
The DWP will not be seeking out claimants who could be entitled to this payment. So what can you do to to increase claimants' awareness of the Scheme? Remember working with a client who could be entitled?


Additional Information / Comments

Whilst there is little guidance yet published about this scheme, we have detailed what we understand of who it may be / may not be for below.

Claimants who cannot benefit from this scheme include:

  • those who claimed UC purely due to poor advice (the reason for the UC claim must be that their legacy benefit ended)
  • those who had a Severe Disability Premium included in a legacy benefit award in the month before their UC claim (as they should have already received compensation for the loss in benefit income when moving onto UC)
  • those who had a claim in circumstances between their legacy benefit ending and claiming UC that would have triggered a claim for UC anyway 
  • those who waited for over a month after their legacy benefit was ended before making their claim for UC.

Claimants who could benefit from this scheme, but could be put off by the wording in the information / application form include:

  • those who challenged the decision to terminate their legacy benefit, but did not request an Appeal ie. the decision was overturned following a Mandatory Reconsideration / Review, or even just a phone call asking why their legacy benefit had been terminated. It was confirmed at a DWP Stakeholders meeting that the Scheme extends to those who had requested an MR / Review and we believe it could extend to anyone who had their legacy benefit termination decision revised.
  • those whose legacy benefit was terminated because the DWP / HB Office didn't have the full facts of the case at the time they made their decision ie. this Scheme isn't just for cases of 'official error'.  

 

IMPORTANT:
Whilst the Scheme is called 'The Successful Legacy Appeals Compensation Scheme', claimants who had the decision to close their legacy benefit overturned following a Mandatory Reconsideration could also be entitled, so should not be put off making an application.


How Much

Claimants found entitled to compensation will receive a one-off lump sum payment. The gov.uk website says that “the lump sum is worked out by taking the biggest monthly loss and multiplying it by 12”. 

It is unclear how this will be worked out, but it would make sense that it will look at the amount of legacy benefits they would have received if their legacy benefit had not been terminated and compare this to the amount of UC awarded. 

This is different from considering the amount of legacy benefit that was in payment at the point the termination decision was made.

The reason why we believe the DWP should look at the amount of legacy benefit that claimant would have received is that the change that resulted in the termination could have increased their entitlement to that legacy benefit – one example would be where a working age couple had one of their legacy benefits terminated when they became a mixed age couple.


Click here for more information on the Scheme and who may be entttled


NOTE: Correct at time of publication, subject to change.

More Articles: