Housing Systems: Combating poverty and sustaining tenancies.
Search
Articles

Change to how UT decisions are reported

and how to weigh up conflicting UT decisions

Published 23rd April 2025

The ‘Upper Tribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber)’ is the source of most of the UK’s case law on social security issues. There are two recent changes to how the Upper Tribunal reports and publishes its decisions. As of 7th April 2025, this practice statement says:

1. All final decisions made by the Upper Tribunal will now be published in the National Archives: https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/

Previously, only decisions of "wider interest" (about a third of them) were made officially available on the internet - this would have included those 'reported' as well as those with three judges.
 

2. The UT will no longer select a handful of decisions of special significance each year to be "reported". Previously, reported decisions (cited in the format '[2018] AACR 5' or 'R(IS)1/03') would be given precedence over unreported decisions, in the event of a conflict.

NOTE: ‘Decisions of wider interest’ will continue to be available on the UT website at: https://www.gov.uk/administrative-appeals-tribunal-decisions. Cases of wider interest can always be identified because they are given a 'neutral citation number', in the format '[2025] UKUT 85 (AAC)'. They will also include a useful case summary.

What about those UT with a three-judge panel?
There is no change to the practice of the UT to occasionally convene a three-judge panel, to settle an issue on which there have been previous conflicting UT decisions. These three-judge UT decisions (which are meant to reduce the need for applications to the Court of Appeal) will still carry the most weight; followed by UT decisions published with neutral citation numbers; followed by other UT decisions which are only assigned an application number in the normal format, such as UA-2022-001763-PIP,  which is given to every UT application.

 

How to weigh up Upper Tribunal decisions that conflict with each other?

If you are arguing a benefit appeal at the First Tier Tribunal, you may want to find if there are previous Upper Tribunal decisions which support your case. More often than not, finding a legal precedent isn't really needed though. If there is no dispute over how to interpret the relevant law, and the FTT only need to investigate your client’s particular facts, then there might never have been a need for the Upper Tribunal to weigh in on the issues raised by your case. Or, the legal questions might be now so well settled and widely known, that there is now no need to cite case law dating from when that groundwork was being established.

However, if the interpretation you are trying to argue for might be disputed, then it can be very useful if you can find a supportive Upper Tribunal decision. Upper Tribunal decisions are binding on First Tier Tribunals - if the facts of the case match, then the First Tier have to apply the Upper Tribunal's interpretation of the law. But what if you find more than one piece of case law that seems relevant, and they apparently contradict each other? There is no single correct approach to this, but we give some general guidance below.

Firstly, it's not a good idea to only mention the favourable case, and hope the tribunal or the DWP don't know about the less favourable one. You will usually have a better chance of winning if you raise everything that appears to be relevant, and explain why one decision should be preferred over another in your case.

If you find UT cases which are in conflict with each other, you could consider:

  • Is a decision actually relevant to your case, i.e. are they based on the same sort of facts? Or can your case be "distinguished", which means you can argue the case law just doesn’t apply at all in your case, no matter how authoritative it might be?
  • Was a conflict between UT decisions ever resolved by a decision of higher authority? As well as the higher courts, also consider for example: three-judge UT panels, persuasive decisions from other jurisdictions, and so on. UT decisions that were reported (before April 2025) can still be significant, but we can not just assume that an old reported decision should have greater weight than a decision that’s published after 7th April 2025, when the practice of reporting was discontinued.
  • What if you find a UT decision that has only been made available in the National Archives, but it matches your case and supports your argument? You could cite it as relevant case law, but be aware that if it hasn't been given a neutral citation number then there may be other UT decisions out there which should carry more weight.

Some more technical considerations, if needed:

  • Was the Upper Tribunal's interpretation of the issue actually needed in order to decide the case law you are looking at? If a Judge or Commissioner included in their decision a line of reasoning that wasn't necessary either way in order to produce the outcome, then you can argue that those parts of the judgement don't necessarily have to be followed by future tribunals. Sometimes a judge will even state this in their judgement - in legalese they might say that certain of their comments are "obiter" and don't form part of the "ratio" of the decision.
  • Which UT decision is more recent? Later decisions can - at least arguably - carry more weight. This could be particularly if the later decision explicitly considered the previous one, and explained why they think it would be an error to follow it. This isn't a hard and fast rule - some old decisions might not have made much sense even at the time, and have been quietly forgotten about; but others can still be frequently referred to, and have stood the test of time.
  • Were the issues in question properly argued in each case? Arguably, preference should be given to a decision that had the benefit of full legal arguments on both sides when arriving at its judgement.

This is by no means a comprehensive summary of how to use conflicting case law, but hopefully can help you head in the right direction. And don’t forget – if the case law is not on your side, that doesn’t mean there is never any point in continuing. Over-turning old legal precedents is how we can create new case law!

 


NOTE: Correct at time of publication, subject to change.

More Articles: